Cookbook Revisions

[philipc2]

Overview

• Cookbook revisions for the 2025 AMS Short Course

[github-actions]

👋 Thanks for opening this PR! The Cookbook will be automatically built with GitHub Actions. To see the status of your deployment, click below.
🔍 Git commit SHA: 9b0c4c3
✅ Deployment Preview URL: https://ProjectPythia.github.io/unstructured-grid-viz-cookbook/_preview/23

[erogluorhan]

Now that we have all the never folders, we can and should remove the older dirs starting with "_01", "_02", and "_03", right?

[philipc2]

Now that we have all the never folders, we can and should remove the older dirs starting with "_01", "_02", and "_03", right?

Yes we can remove them now.

[erogluorhan]

Overall this looks great! I really enjoyed reading them all under the Plotting with UXarray and the Recipes. Just a few things to note:

• There were only a few typos to correct that I've already fixed. No action there for you.
• The content of MPAS Atmosphere and MPAS Ocean feels like atmosphere should come before ocean (e.g. there are more MPAS insights delivered in the atmosphere one, and it feels like a more comprehensive recipe)
• MPAS ocean has no text at all once the plotting code starts. Is it intentional? I don't have big issues with that since the plotting is pretty self-explanatory (though it may feel so to us only), but it feels a bit awkward compared to the rest of the cookbook.

[philipc2]

There were only a few typos to correct that I've already fixed. No action there for you.

Thanks for correcting these!

The content of MPAS Atmosphere and MPAS Ocean feels like atmosphere should come before ocean (e.g. there are more MPAS insights delivered in the atmosphere one, and it feels like a more comprehensive recipe)

That's a good idea.

MPAS ocean has no text at all once the plotting code starts. Is it intentional? I don't have big issues with that since the plotting is pretty self-explanatory (though it may feel so to us only), but it feels a bit awkward compared to the rest of the cookbook.

Yeah, I couldn't come up with much when I was writing it. I will at least populate some small markdown describing the plots.

[philipc2]

@erogluorhan

For the mpas-ocean visual, I've added markdown that discusses the choice for using a vector-polygon approach for the subset (since it is small and only contaisn 164) elements and the choice for using a raster-polygon for the global grid. I think that additional info should tell a good story.

[philipc2]

I've also populated the E3SM recipie

If you have a chance @rytam2, may you skim over it and make sure I didn't incorrectly list anything. This is a slightly modified version of the user guide you put together.

[erogluorhan]

I gave this a second review now, and all look good to me except that the Comparison to Xarray does not show up in the preview though its notebook seems populated.

[philipc2]

I gave this a second review now, and all look good to me except that the Comparison to Xarray does not show up in the preview though its notebook seems populated.

Oops. I'll fix that.