Building for RISCV64?

[matsbror]

Did anyone try to build for RISCV64?

The regular Make (with TARGET set to riscv64gc-unknown-linux-gnu) doesn't work.

[radu-matei]

Hey, @matsbror, thank you for reporting this.
Would you mind sharing the output of running the build command, please?

For context, we do know at least the Wasmtime / Spin dependency for the shim (the part executing Wasm) does compile and run correctly on RISC-V.
I don't have a lot of context for the containerd / youki dependencies, so paging @Mossaka for some help on it.

[matsbror]

I am on v0.13.1. On my RISCV64-board, I try to build it directly like:

cargo build --release --target riscv64gc-unknown-linux-gnu --manifest-path=containerd-shim-spin/Cargo.toml                                                                                            

as I had issues with the Makefile

It fails trying to compile ring.

error: failed to run custom build command for `ring v0.16.20`

I have wasmtime cli running fine so I know that that part is working. I remember I had issues with the ring crate a long time ago when running the sightglass benchmarks in wasmtime. Then I believe I resolved by using a local copy of precision which used ring. Ring 0.17 has resolved the issue on RISCV, but these are the crates in Cargo.lock that refers to ring v0.16.20:

• aws-config (I don't care about this)
• rustls

aws-config in turns is used by trigger-sqs and rustls used by wasmtime-wasi-http, which I definitely want.

I will continue to investigate if there is a way to remove or upgrade these dependencies so that ring 0.17.8 is used instead.

EDIT: I should add that I get the same error when cross-compiling on an x86 machine.

[radu-matei]

Adding @tschneidereit who had success running Spin on a RISCV64 board.

[matsbror]

I managed to build runwasi by removing the Cargo.lock file so that cargo could rebuild the dependencies from scratch. That did not work for this repo. However, the issue lies in trigger-sqs. As far as I understand, this is related to AWS and I do not intend to use AWS for this project (now RISCV-instances there :-) so how can I remove that dependency?

[radu-matei]

We should put the other triggers behind Cargo features, to make this kind of thing easier.

Specifically, to unblock your use case, you can:

• comment the dependency in Cargo.toml: https://github.com/spinkube/containerd-shim-spin/blob/main/containerd-shim-spin/Cargo.toml#L24
• comment https://github.com/spinkube/containerd-shim-spin/blob/main/containerd-shim-spin/src/engine.rs#L238-L246 and https://github.com/spinkube/containerd-shim-spin/blob/main/containerd-shim-spin/src/engine.rs#L484

[matsbror]

Unfortunately I still do not have success. spin-trigger-http needs tokio-rustls which needs rustls which uses `ring 0.16.20.
I tried to force cargo to replace ring 0.16.20 with 0.17.8 using:

[replace]
"ring:0.16.20" = { git = "https://github.com/briansmith/ring" }

at the top-level Cargo.toml, but it failed as rustls required v0.16.20

[tschneidereit]

When I experimented with this last Fall, there was no version of Ring released that would've supported RISCV, so I hacked something up that Worked On My Machine.

By now this should all be much easier, luckily: there's a pretty recent release of tokio-rustls that depends on ring 0.17, which should be recent enough, I think. I don't know how involved updating tokio-rustls would be, but I'd hope that it's not too heavy a lift.

[matsbror]

Thanks @tschneidereit , but how do I replace the dependency on ring or tokio-rustls as they are not top-level dependencies?

[tschneidereit]

it seems like tokio-rustls is the dependency to replace/update here. If we're really lucky, the version of that which (via its updated ring dependency) supports RISCV is API-compatible for our purposes. If that is the case, you should be able to get a build by adding this to your project's Cargo.toml file:

[patch.crates-io]
tokio-rustls = { git = 'https://github.com/rustls/tokio-rustls.git', tag = "v/0.26.0" }

If that doesn't work out of the box, it's possible that slight adjustments would fix it.

If that works, a PR to the spin repo updating the dependency would be fantastic!

[matsbror]

I managed to resolve the issue for me.

I updated the dependency in spin/crates/trigger-http/Cargo.toml of tokio-rustls to version 0.24.1. That was enough to push ring to version 0.17.8 without breaking anything else.

This one resolved the issue for containerd-shim-spin also but I had to add a dependency to spin-ecpressions in the spin repo.

However, I cannot (now) make a PR for spin on this as I am not able to run tests (even on main branch) and I know too little to fix it.