python3-rosdep-modules and python-rosdep-modules not side-by-side installable with version 0.19.0-1

[sloretz]

It looks like python(3)-rosdep-modules incorrectly depend on the non-"modules" packages on Bionic, and because of that they're not side-by-side installable.

From http://packages.ros.org/ros/ubuntu/dists/bionic/main/binary-amd64/Packages

Package: python3-rosdep-modules
Priority: optional
Section: python
Installed-Size: 310
Maintainer: Tully Foote, Ken Conley <[email protected]>
Architecture: all
Version: 0.19.0-1
Replaces: python3-rosdep (<< 0.18.0)
Depends: python3-catkin-pkg, python3-rosdistro, python3-rospkg, python3-yaml, python3:any (>= 3.4~), ca-certificates, python3-rospkg-modules (>= 1.1.10), python3-catkin-pkg-modules (>= 0.4.0), python3-rosdistro-modules (>= 0.7.5), sudo
Conflicts: python3-rosdep (<< 0.18.0), python3-rosdep2
Filename: pool/main/p/python3-rosdep-modules/python3-rosdep-modules_0.19.0-1_all.deb
SHA512: f08abea3c1f8efb4bad10b027b4f0129c0bd56c8b70e49e994226f5bebf45bec6a64ea230fa2a810b67341ae74b61ba930e11e0db30b062ef8dddabf0112e8c0
Size: 50552
SHA256: a29a4f8215e6bdc2b44a029beb31e3719a50b288e84a756f478436e7c8b0fd52
SHA1: 431c37ca31925b04bb1d65081bddf045be6d6607
MD5sum: cdab4a33c901c7548ba9c75949a0f185
Description: rosdep package manager abstraction tool for ROS
 Command-line tool for installing system dependencies on a variety of platforms.

The problem is python3-catkin-pkg, python3-rosdistro, python3-rospkg are present in Depends when they should not be. Same problem for the Python 2 package

Package: python-rosdep-modules
Priority: optional
Section: python
Installed-Size: 311
Maintainer: Tully Foote, Ken Conley <[email protected]>
Architecture: all
Version: 0.19.0-1
Replaces: python-rosdep (<< 0.18.0)
Depends: python (<< 2.8), python (>= 2.7), python-catkin-pkg, python-rosdistro, python-rospkg, python-yaml, python:any (>= 2.6.6-7~), ca-certificates, python-rospkg-modules (>= 1.1.10), python-catkin-pkg-modules (>= 0.4.0), python-rosdistro-modules (>= 0.7.5), sudo
Conflicts: python-rosdep (<< 0.18.0), python-rosdep2
Filename: pool/main/p/python-rosdep-modules/python-rosdep-modules_0.19.0-1_all.deb
SHA512: 2b5931d127d0aa8a8d83274cfd124b67a5b65bd0a31c5f8e4e6f5e10ddd3cc65904a0ae6a63b27c86d60cea85006902de92c23b8b047e171f06787090b685bbd
Size: 50548
SHA256: e3f7fb5bab52dbe15475c1ba88d505db9d1519a809f4f1d3e655430f40d515c2
SHA1: 13419cf7820ea4c7efa9a28060d16ca3244a6a9a
MD5sum: 2bd786f9ce7c4708333159d0b79605cd
Description: rosdep package manager abstraction tool for ROS
 Command-line tool for installing system dependencies on a variety of platforms.

The Depends line incorrectly has python-catkin-pkg, python-rosdistro, python-rospkg`

Same issue in Focal http://packages.ros.org/ros/ubuntu/dists/focal/main/binary-amd64/Packages, though here it doesn't matter since there's no Python 2 modules package to conflict with.

Package: python3-rosdep-modules
Priority: optional
Section: python
Installed-Size: 310
Maintainer: Tully Foote, Ken Conley <[email protected]>
Architecture: all
Version: 0.19.0-1
Replaces: python3-rosdep (<< 0.18.0)
Depends: python3-catkin-pkg, python3-rosdistro, python3-rospkg, python3-yaml, python3:any (>= 3.4~), ca-certificates, python3-rospkg-modules (>= 1.1.10), python3-catkin-pkg-modules (>= 0.4.0), python3-rosdistro-modules (>= 0.7.5), sudo
Conflicts: python3-rosdep (<< 0.18.0), python3-rosdep2
Filename: pool/main/p/python3-rosdep-modules/python3-rosdep-modules_0.19.0-1_all.deb
SHA512: f08abea3c1f8efb4bad10b027b4f0129c0bd56c8b70e49e994226f5bebf45bec6a64ea230fa2a810b67341ae74b61ba930e11e0db30b062ef8dddabf0112e8c0
Size: 50552
SHA256: a29a4f8215e6bdc2b44a029beb31e3719a50b288e84a756f478436e7c8b0fd52
SHA1: 431c37ca31925b04bb1d65081bddf045be6d6607
MD5sum: cdab4a33c901c7548ba9c75949a0f185
Description: rosdep package manager abstraction tool for ROS
 Command-line tool for installing system dependencies on a variety of platforms.

[sloretz]

@nuclearsandwich anything different about the 0.19.0 release? I'm not sure where to start looking; it seems like stdeb.cfg is ok:

rosdep/stdeb.cfg

Lines 19 to 20 in d1784da

	Depends: ca-certificates, python-rospkg-modules (>= 1.1.10), python-yaml, python-catkin-pkg-modules (>= 0.4.0), python-rosdistro-modules (>= 0.7.5), sudo
	Depends3: ca-certificates, python3-rospkg-modules (>= 1.1.10), python3-yaml, python3-catkin-pkg-modules (>= 0.4.0), python3-rosdistro-modules (>= 0.7.5), sudo

[nuclearsandwich]

@nuclearsandwich anything different about the 0.19.0 release? I'm not sure where to start looking; it seems like stdeb.cfg is ok:

No actually. The rosdep packages have never been co-installable. #731 and #750 have both gotten us closer but we're still not there yet.

The problem here is the same dependency guessing issue we face with bloom adding a depending on rosdep2 from upstream Debian/Ubuntu. Unfortunately the workaround we use there (release from a distribution that doesn't have upstream packages to guess is harder since our supported platforms all have either python2 or python3 versions of these packages in upstream. I've got a PR started to add config options for stdeb to control the dependency guessing but it won't be ready today.

[dirk-thomas]

I would guess dh is guessing the additional Debian packages based on the dependencies declare in the setup.py file. Since we do need those for pip they could be conditionally removed when building .deb packages since the necessary dependencies are explicitly enumerated in the stdeb.cfg file.