Blocking a specific message from a device #17330
Replies: 6 comments 16 replies
-
AFAIK there is no way to reduce the spamming of these TuYa devices. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
@Littleislandbrewing what do you mean by debounce? I’m having the same issue and I feel anything will help. Can you please explain what you did and how I can do the same? @Koenkk it’d be amazing if you can figure out a way to fix this, honestly. The network is getting bogged down now. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
Sorry, but I don't know a way to reduce TuYa message spamming, I believe it also occurs when using it with their gateway. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
I had 6 of these on my Conbee, and it killed the whole network. Have since then removed all and switched to the SkyConnect - wondering if I should try adding one or two again now.. Does debounce then also delay the time from sensing to logging in HA? |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
This is going to become more and more of an issue as these devices gain in popularity and fall in price. To me this is a perfect example of why sometimes 2 Zigbee networks makes sense. The chatty devices could be placed on a separate coordinator using a different topic than the main network and then let them do all the talking they want amongst themselves. It would be really nice if Z2M had a built in accommodation to handle multiple coordinators running on the same MQTT broker while using separate topics. --Barry |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
So the tuya zigbee presence detector arrived two days ago. When you relied on infrared motion detector the past years and all your family members hated you because of the false-non-detection... this seems to be a new chaptor now. No more lights off when people are sitting still in the room 🗡️ Anyway: Yes they are spammy and like I said I excluded them from my main network by creating a new VM on my ESXI host. I Only had an old CC2531, but well. It's working. What I did and if someone is stumbling here:
I wanted to exclude all the spammy messages from my main zigbee network and my homeassistant instance. Perhaps you could just use a second zigbee network and directly connect to the main homeassistant instance. That would avoid lots of configuration on the second smarthome software, where I filter everything and just send the presence payload to the home assistant mqtt broker. It works. Perhaps it would've also worked by just adding the radar devices to my main network and don't give a F... Currently I don't know how I should go ahead: Take the wifi versions since wifi is more used to so much spammy messages and device interaction or stick to the plan and have a messy zigbee network with all radar devices... |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
hello peeps.
I have a bunch of Tuya Radars and they are spamming the network.
I have managed to slow down the amount of spam by using debounce: 1 and it works reasonably well with proper messages - however there is still some noisy spam that looks like this>
How do I filter on type 'commandDataReport' or 'dpValues' for the whole message???
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions