Current methods of IPopupService.ClosePopup and IPopupService.ClosePopupAsync don't recognize which popup really closing

[yevgeny-sotnikov]

I have concurrent code which can open few popups at the same time, one is progress popup, another - popup with entry field for data editing. They are opened simultaneously from different places so i can't manage order of their opening.

When i call ClosePopup/ClosePopupAsync at code related to progress I'm getting incorrect result at code related to popup with entry field.

So I'm asking about possibility to add popup order management inside CommunityToolkit code

Thank you

[bijington]

The default implementation just closes the last displayed popup.

You can create your own implementation of https://github.com/CommunityToolkit/Maui/blob/main/src/CommunityToolkit.Maui/Popup/IPopupLifecycleController.cs and assign it to the LifecycleController property on PopupService.

[yevgeny-sotnikov]

@bijington but why when i call ClosePopup at code related to progress/activity indication popup - i still getting its result at code related to data entering popup with throwing invalid cast exception?

[bijington]

Is the code related to data entering being called last in that scenario? If so then this still fits with my expectation on the current implementation although it's difficult to say without seeing this in code.

I can try to play around with Popups to see if they misbehave

[acaliaro]

I have concurrent code which can open few popups at the same time, one is progress popup, another - popup with entry field for data editing. They are opened simultaneously from different places so i can't manage order of their opening.

When i call ClosePopup/ClosePopupAsync at code related to progress I'm getting incorrect result at code related to popup with entry field.

So I'm asking about possibility to add popup order management inside CommunityToolkit code

Thank you

#1973